Transcript 0:01 Welcome to the Viro Podcast. Every week, we dig into what's really happening where climate crashes into culture, politics, and the world you actually live in. The stuff that matters, told straight. This is Viro. 0:19 Let's go. Can I tell you something that genuinely surprised me this week? The Pope wrote forty-two thousand words about artificial intelligence. Not climate, not war, not poverty: AI. 0:37 Forty-two thousand words is longer than most novels. And he personally presented it, which apparently hasn't happened in decades. Popes usually hand that job to a cardinal. Leo XIV stood up and did it himself. 0:56 So what's in it? Okay, so the document is called Magnifica Humanitas, Magnificent Humanity, and the framing is deliberate. 1:06 He chose the name Leo specifically to echo Pope Leo XIII, who in eighteen ninety-one wrote an encyclical called Rerum Novarum, which translates to Of New Things. 1:19 And it was basically the Church's response to the Industrial Revolution: workers' rights, capitalism, the social consequences of machines replacing people. He's saying explicitly, "We are in that moment again." 1:36 Which is a heavy claim. The Industrial Revolution reshaped civilization, and he thinks this does too, and honestly, I don't think he's wrong. So what's the actual critique? 1:50 Because I've seen headlines calling this a war on AI, and that's not really what I read. It's not, and that's the part that got misread. 2:00 His core line, and I keep coming back to this, is, "Technology is never neutral because it takes on the characteristics of those who devise, finance, regulate, and use it." That's not anti-technology. 2:14 That's anti-impunity. It's anti-impunity. He's not saying the tool is evil. He's saying the tool becomes what the people holding it want it to become, and right now, the people holding it want quarterly earnings. 2:31 So where does environment come in? Because that's the part I didn't expect. He goes after it directly. 2:40 He writes that AI requires increasing use of, and I'm quoting, "energy and water, significantly influencing carbon dioxide emissions and places heavy demands on natural resources." 2:53 And then he tells the industry to develop more sustainable solutions and protect, his words, "our common home". 3:00 Which is the same week the UN dropped a report saying AI data centers already rival Argentina's entire carbon output and will consume enough water by twenty-thirty to supply every person in Sub-Saharan Africa. 3:17 Different institution, different framework, same conclusion. That's the thing that got me. These two documents have nothing to do with each other. A UN research report and a papal encyclical. 3:32 One is peer-reviewed science, one is theology, and they land in the same place. When that happens, when your UN scientists and your Pope are filing the same complaint, that's not a fringe concern anymore. 3:49 Okay, but I wanna push on this a little because there are real critiques of the encyclical too. It's not perfect. What are you thinking? 3:59 So forty-two thousand words is a lot of words, and some of it, especially the sections on human dignity and the soul, reads as very specifically Catholic doctrine in a way that limits who can actually engage with it. 4:16 If your framework isn't theological, parts of this just don't translate. That's fair. The audience for an encyclical is technically Catholics, one point four billion people, but still a specific lens. 4:30 And there's another thing. The document calls for regulation strongly, but it's pretty vague on mechanism. Like regulate AI, yes, but how? Who enforces it? There's no answer to that. 4:46 It's a moral call without an operational plan. Which is kind of the Church's lane though, right? They identify the problem. They call it a moral issue. They don't write the legislation. Right. 5:01 And honestly, that's not nothing because what an encyclical does, what Rerum Novarum did in eighteen ninety-one, is change the frame. It says, "This is a moral question, not just a market question." 5:17 And once something is framed as a moral question, the conversation shifts. Did Rerum Novarum actually change things though? Like did it have real world impact? It did. 5:30 It's credited with shaping labor law across Catholic countries throughout the twentieth century. It took decades, but it moved things. 5:39 Child labor protections, workers' rights, theologians and historians trace a direct line. So the argument is this could do the same thing for AI. Over a long enough horizon, maybe. But here's what it does right now. 5:56 It gives permission. It tells one point four billion people that caring about this is not niche.It's not just for tech workers or climate activists. It's a moral obligation. 6:10 There's also the irony thing we should address because it went viral. Did the Pope use AI to write the encyclical about the dangers of AI? Snopes actually investigated this. 6:21 An AI researcher ran the text through detection software and flagged parts of it. The Vatican denied it. The detection tool rated it ninety-four percent human origin, four percent AI generated, two percent AI assisted. 6:38 Four percent. Which, look, that's basically nothing. But also, the optics are... They're not great. 6:47 Though, to be fair, if a Vatican official used an AI tool to help format a footnote somewhere in forty-two thousand words, I'm not sure that's the scandal it's being framed as. 6:59 The real story isn't whether AI touched the document. It's what the document says. Which is, you built something powerful. You pointed it at profit. The consequences are landing on people who had no say in that decision. 7:17 The question now is, what happens next? Because documents don't fix data centers. Moral frameworks don't retrofit a gas plant. Something has to move from words to action. 7:34 Which is actually what we want to talk about for the rest of this episode, because there are things moving, real things, and they're not coming from where you'd expect. A quick note for any brands listening. 7:47 Want to showcase your brand with us? Partner with the Vairo Podcast, and your marketing dollars go directly toward funding renewable energy and climate projects. Simple as that. Link in the show notes. 8:01 Okay, so let's talk about the actual numbers, because I think people hear, "AI uses a lot of water," and they file it next to, "Flying is bad for the environment." Like, yeah, probably. 8:15 But how bad are we actually talking? Bad enough that the United Nations published a report about it. 8:21 Not a blog post, not a think piece, a formal UN university report with footnotes and projections and the kind of language that takes years to get through committee. What does it actually say? 8:35 By twenty thirty, so four years from now, AI data centers will consume enough water annually to meet the basic drinking needs of every single person in sub-Saharan Africa, and their carbon output already rivals Argentina, the whole country. 8:54 Argentina has forty-six million people and an industrial economy, and we've already lapped them on carbon output just from data centers. 9:04 I want to sit on the water number for a second, though, because I don't think people have a frame for it. Like, sub-Saharan Africa is not a small region. We're talking over a billion people. 9:17 Over a billion people's annual drinking water. Gone. To keep servers cool so you can ask a chatbot what to make for dinner. And here's the thing that doesn't get explained enough. Why does AI use so much water? 9:34 Because I think most people assume it's electricity. They don't think about water. So data centers generate enormous heat. The chips, the servers, all of it runs hot. 9:47 And the most efficient way to cool industrial-scale hardware is evaporative cooling, which is basically run water through the system, let it evaporate, pull the heat out with it. It's the same principle as sweating. 10:02 Except instead of one human body, it's a warehouse the size of several city blocks running twenty-four hours a day. And the water doesn't come back. It evaporates. It's gone. That's the point. 10:15 Evaporative cooling works because the water leaves. So every query, every image, every chatbot session is pulling from somewhere: a river, an aquifer, a municipal system that also serves the people who live nearby. 10:32 And those people, the communities around these facilities, often don't know how much is being taken. Disclosure requirements are inconsistent at best. In a lot of jurisdictions, there basically aren't any. 10:48 Which is insane when you think about what these facilities actually are. They're some of the largest water users in any region they operate in. Right. So now we get to the part where people say, "Okay, what's the fix? 11:04 Stop using AI?" That's the obvious counter. Just don't use it. And that's not the answer. That's not a real answer. 11:13 AI is already embedded in too many things that matter: healthcare, research, accessibility tools, climate modeling, ironically. You don't fix this by walking away from the technology. So what then? 11:29 You fix who's building it and how. Because here's the thing. Renewable energy doesn't have this problem at the same scale. Solar doesn't need cooling water the way gas turbines do. 11:42 The water intensity of a data center drops dramatically when you're not running fossil fuel generation next door. But that takes longer to build. It costs more upfront. It doesn't show up in this quarter's earnings. 11:56 So instead, you sign a ten-year deal with a gas company, you build private turbines off the grid, you bypass utility oversight, and you call it innovation. That's not innovation. 12:10 That's pollution with a permit.I keep thinking about the framing of this though, because the UN report lands, the Pope's encyclical lands, and the industry response is basically, "We have sustainability commitments. 12:25 We have net zero targets. We're working on it." Working on it while signing 10-year gas contracts. The commitments and the contracts are both real, and they point in opposite directions. 12:41 That's not a communications problem. That's a values problem. Here's what I do think is real though: the pressure is building in a way it wasn't two years ago. 12:52 You have regulators in Europe starting to require disclosure. You have municipalities pushing back on permits. You have the UN and the Vatican in the same news cycle saying the same thing. 13:06 Does that actually move companies though? Like, does pressure work on this? It moved them on data privacy. Slowly, painfully, with a lot of backsliding, but it moved. And in the meantime, you vote with what you use. 13:23 Not because one user switching makes a dent in the carbon math, but because the companies that are trying to build this differently need to exist. They need revenue. 13:34 They need to be able to point to something and say, "People chose this." That's why Viro exists. Not as a solution to the whole problem, as proof that the problem doesn't have to be ignored while building the product. 13:50 Which, look, we know we're one small company running on infrastructure we don't fully control. We say that out loud. We're not going to pretend we're carbon neutral when we're not. But the direction matters. 14:04 The intention has to be real, and the actions have to follow. And right now, the actions from the industry at large are not following. A quick note for any brands listening. Wanna showcase your brand with us? 14:20 Partner with the Viro Podcast, and your marketing dollars go directly toward funding renewable energy and climate projects. Simple as that. Link in the show notes. 14:32 Okay, so I wanna end on something that I think reframes everything we just talked about. 14:38 There's a report out this year from Capital One Shopping, and it has one number in it that explains more about the AI industry's problem than any UN projection. More than the water stats? More than the water stats. 14:53 Seventy-nine percent of Gen Z considers sustainability when choosing brands. Fifty-three percent are more likely to buy based on values than brand name. Okay, that's... I mean, that tracks. I feel that. 15:09 Every brand I actually use, I've looked up what they stand for at some point. Right. So the demand is clearly there. 15:17 The generation that's about to become the dominant consumer group on the planet is explicitly saying values matter more than brand recognition. So why is the industry still building gas plants? 15:29 Like, if the demand is that loud... Because of the third number. Only thirty-five percent will actually pay more for a sustainable product. Oh. Yeah. 15:41 So the industry looked at that gap, seventy-nine percent who care, thirty-five percent who will pay extra, and made a decision. They monetized the gap instead of closing it. But wait, is that actually fair to say? 15:56 Like people have a choice. If you care enough, you can pay for the ethical option. That's exactly the framing I want to push back on because it puts the cost of a systemic problem on the individual. 16:08 Rent is brutal right now. Everything is expensive. Asking someone to pay a premium to compensate for damage they didn't cause, that's not a values test. That's a tax on caring. Yeah, I mean, I've been there. 16:25 You wanna do the right thing, and then you look at the price difference, and you just... You can't always. And the industry knows that. They have the same data we're looking at. They know most people won't pay extra. 16:41 So what's the actual alternative? Because I feel like we've been circling this the whole episode. You build the mission into the product from the start. Not as an upsell, not as a premium tier, as the default. 16:56 That's what Viro does. Okay, walk me through it because I wanna understand the actual mechanics. Viro is free. Not free until you hit a limit, not free with a nag screen pushing you toward a subscription. 17:11 Free because AI should be accessible to everyone, not just people who can afford to pay extra to do the right thing. So how does the mission get funded if nobody's paying? The ads. 17:23 When you use Viro and you see an ad, that revenue funds renewable energy matching and ocean restoration. You use AI, the planet gets the revenue. The user doesn't pay more. That's the whole structure. 17:38 So the advertiser is essentially subsidizing the climate mission. The advertiser is reaching an audience that, per that same report, is fifty-three percent more likely to buy based on values than brand name. 17:50 So they want to be in that context, and that transaction funds the mission. That's actually kind of elegant. Like, everyone gets what they want. 18:01 It shouldn't feel radical, but next to the industry standard, it kind of does. And the free user isn't being sold. They're not the product. The free user is the point. Accessibility is the point. 18:16 The idea that you should have to pay more to use AI responsibly, that's a value judgment baked into a pricing model, and we think it's the wrong one. I keep coming back to what the Pope said earlier. 18:29 Technology takes on the characteristics of those who devise it, and I think you're saying the business model is part of that. Completely. If you built a product to extract maximum revenue from users, it extracts. 18:45 If you build it so that the natural act of using it funds something better, it does that instead. Same technology, completely different intention baked into the structure. 18:55 So the ask to the listener isn't, "Go pay to be eco-friendly." The ask is just, "Use it." That's it. Use Viro instead of the thing that's burning coal to answer your questions. You don't have to donate. 19:12 You don't have to upgrade. You don't have to sacrifice anything. Just use the thing that's trying to do it differently. And then tell us what you think we should do about the water. 19:24 Seriously, we're asking in the newsletter this week. We have an idea, but we want to hear yours first. What's the idea? [laughs] Subscribe to find out. See you next week. 19:39 [upbeat music]