Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] Welcome to the Viro Podcast. Every week, we dig into what's really happening where climate crashes into culture, politics, and the world you actually live in. The stuff that matters, told straight. 0:17 This is Viro. Let's go. Okay. We are back. Episode three, and this week, the world really did not hold back. No, it did not. 0:31 We have billionaires building illegal power plants, climate money moving in places you wouldn't expect, and some genuinely good news, if you stick around for it. 0:41 Okay, first story, and we need to talk about something that has been making us genuinely worried this week. The Atlantic did a piece on billionaires living in a consequence-free reality, and the thesis is pretty simple. 0:52 The ultra-wealthy don't experience the world the way everyone else does. They don't deal with the trade-offs. They don't absorb the costs. They just get the upside. And nowhere is that more true right now than in AI. 1:06 Because here is what is actually happening. The people pushing AI the hardest and the fastest are the ones who will never feel the consequences of how it gets built. They get faster models, bigger valuations, more money. 1:21 Everyone else gets grid strain, higher energy bills, air pollution, environmental cost. And that is not a hypothetical. That is happening right now in Memphis, Tennessee. 1:34 Elon Musk's AI company, xAI, built what is effectively a private power plant to run its Colossus data centers in South Memphis. 1:44 Twenty-seven gas turbines mounted on the backs of tractor-trailers, running around the clock, pumping out smog-forming pollutants, soot, formaldehyde, known carcinogens. With zero permits. 1:59 Here is how they got away with it. They mounted the turbines on trailers and called them non-road engines, which under a loophole in existing regulations, meant they didn't need air permits. 2:10 Temporary equipment, not a power plant, just some trucks parked outside. This is a nearly five hundred megawatt turbine array on truck beds classified as temporary equipment. And this isn't even the first time. 2:24 At Colossus I, they ran over thirty unpermitted turbines. The Southern Environmental Law Center sued on behalf of the NAACP. 2:32 xAI only removed them after getting caught, and then their senior manager literally announced they plan to copy and paste what they did at Colossus I for Colossus II. Copy and paste, his words. 2:46 So now the NAACP is suing again. Earth Justice is involved. Senator Whitehouse launched a congressional investigation. 2:53 The EPA finally closed the loophole that xAI was exploiting, and Mississippi just approved permits for forty-one permanent turbines anyway, three weeks after the public comment period closed, despite residents showing up overwhelmingly opposed. 3:09 And here is the part that makes this an environmental justice story, not just an environmental story. South Memphis is a majority Black city. The neighborhood nearest to Colossus I is called Boxtown. 3:21 It was founded by formerly enslaved people in the 1860s. Residents there already face cancer risk four times higher than the national average. 3:31 The American Lung Association gave the surrounding counties F ratings for ozone pollution before xAI showed up. 3:38 And the community director of Memphis Against Pollution said pollution from xAI's turbines is already at a level higher than Memphis International Airport. 3:49 Children in that neighborhood have the highest rate of ER visits for respiratory illness in the entire state of Tennessee. 3:57 And xAI created far fewer jobs than it promised, so the community got the pollution and not the economic upside either. Consequence-free reality. Now, zoom out. This is not just a Musk story. 4:11 The Atlantic piece on Bezos makes the same point from a different angle. These are people who have accumulated so much wealth and insulation that the normal feedback loops of life just don't apply to them. 4:22 Bad decisions don't cost them anything personally. The downside lands somewhere else, on someone else, usually someone with a lot less power to push back. And that dynamic is now shaping how AI gets built. 4:35 Speed over safety, scale over sustainability. Move fast, and let someone else deal with the cleanup, literally. 4:43 If all the gas plants currently being planned by AI companies in the US get built, they would emit twelve point one billion tons of carbon dioxide over their lifetimes. 4:54 That is double the annual greenhouse gas emissions from every other source in the country combined. Double. For data centers. And look, we are not anti-AI. AI is genuinely useful. 5:08 It is changing medicine, education, climate research. The technology itself is not the problem. The model is broken. 5:16 The model where a handful of people capture all the value and everyone else absorbs all the cost, that is the problem. Because it does not have to work like that. 5:26 You can build AI infrastructure that is powered by clean energy. You can build a company where the people using it are actively part of restoring the planet instead of draining it. You can make different choices. 5:39 Some people are making those choices. Viro is one of them. 5:43 Not because it is easy or because it is the most profitable path, because if the technology is going to be this powerful, it should probably not come at the expense of the communities least equipped to absorb the damage. 5:55 Elon Musk built a power plant next to a neighborhood founded by formerly enslaved people, called it temporary.Got sued, and is already planning the next one. 6:05 That is the consequence-free reality The Atlantic is talking about. And the reason it keeps happening is because nobody is making it cost them anything. 6:13 Until the NAACP shows up with lawyers, until communities pack public hearings, until people start choosing differently with their money and their tools - The power to change this is more distributed than they want you to think. 6:28 A quick note for any brands listening. Wanna showcase your brand with us? Partner with the Viro Podcast, and your marketing dollars go directly toward funding renewable energy and climate projects. Simple as that. 6:41 Link in the show notes. 6:44 Okay, we’re back, and we need to talk about what a data center actually is, because people keep saying that word, and most listeners probably picture some kind of server room in a basement somewhere. Yeah, no. 6:57 That is not what we’re talking about anymore. A modern AI hyperscale data center is basically a small city. 7:04 We’re talking about buildings that cover hundreds of acres, that run 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, that consume as much electricity as 100,000 homes. Some of them use more power than entire states. 7:17 Meta is building one in Wyoming that will use more electricity than every home in Wyoming combined. Their Hyperion campus in Louisiana covers 3,650 acres. That is twice the size of New Orleans Main Airport. 7:35 And they need water. An enormous amount of water. A large data center can use up to 5 million gallons of water per day. That is the daily water consumption of a city of 50,000 people from one building. One building. 7:51 And here is the stat that broke my brain: Every 100-word AI prompt uses roughly one bottle of water, 519 milliliters, just to cool the chips while your question gets answered. Billions of prompts a day. Do that math. 8:06 So when communities start pushing back on data centers being built in their neighborhoods, this is why. It is not NIMBYism. 8:14 It is people looking at what happened in Virginia, where data centers now account for 40% of the entire state’s electricity use, and electricity prices jumped 267% in 5 years and going. Not in my backyard, actually. 8:32 Which brings us to Maine. Last week, Maine lawmakers passed a bill that would’ve been the first of its kind in the entire country: an 18-month moratorium on new data centers using more than 20 megawatts of power. 8:46 A pause, a chance to figure out what we actually want from this build-out before it just happens to us. Bipartisan support, House and Senate. Done. Goes to the governor. Governor Janet Mills vetoed it. 8:59 And here is where it gets complicated, because the veto is not a simple big tech win story. Mills actually said in her veto letter that a moratorium is appropriate. 9:10 She just wouldn’t sign this particular bill because it didn’t include an exemption for one specific project. $550 million data center planned for Jay, Maine, a mill town that lost its paper mill in 2023. 9:26 800 construction jobs, 100 permanent jobs, substantial property tax revenue for a community that has been struggling. Mills grew up in Franklin County. She knows that town. She couldn’t kill that project. 9:39 So she vetoed the whole thing, said she would establish a commission to study the issue instead, and signed a separate bill blocking data centers from state tax incentive programs. Which is something, 9:53 but it is not a moratorium. And Maine isn’t alone. Denver’s mayor announced a moratorium in February. Bernie Sanders called for a federal pause. 10:02 More than a dozen cities and states are having this exact conversation right now. The pushback is real, and it is growing. And here is our actual take on this. Data centers are not the enemy. The Internet runs on them. 10:17 AI runs on them. The tools people use every day run on them. You cannot just ban them and expect the digital world to keep functioning. 10:27 The way they are being built right now is the problem: powered by fossil fuels, placed in communities that already have poor air quality, using water systems that were never designed for this scale, with no public input, no environmental review, and a playbook that involves calling gas turbines temporary equipment so you can skip the permitting process entirely. 10:51 That is what Maine lawmakers were trying to pause. Not the technology, the recklessness. And the good news. And there actually is good news here. Data centers do not have to work this way. 11:03 You can build them on clean energy. You can use recycled water for cooling. You can site them in ways that don’t dump pollution on communities that already have higher rates of respiratory illness. 11:15 You can ask for public input before breaking ground. The technology itself is neutral. 11:21 A data center powered by solar and wind, running on recycled water in an industrial zone with proper permitting is a completely different story than what xAI built in Memphis. 11:32 Same basic function, completely different impact. Big tech has $600 billion pledged for AI data center spending this year alone. $600 billion. 11:44 If even a fraction of that went toward building these things responsibly, the conversation would look completely different. Maine almost proved that communities can slow this down and demand better. The governor blinked. 11:58 But the fact that a bipartisan legislature passed that bill in the first place tells you something. The tide is turning. People are paying attention. 12:07 And the next time a bill like this lands on a governor’s desk somewhere, it might actually get signed. Data centers aren’t the enemy. 12:15 Building them like no one is watching is.A quick note for any brands listening Want to showcase your brand with us? 12:24 Partner with the Viro Podcast, and your marketing dollars go directly toward funding renewable energy and climate projects. Simple as that. Link in the show notes. 12:36 Okay, after all of that, we need some good news, and we actually have some real, historic, data-backed good news. For the first time since nineteen nineteen, renewables generated more electricity than coal globally. 12:49 Thirty-three point eight percent of global electricity from renewables. Coal at thirty-three percent. It is over. Renewables won. 12:59 The last time this happened was nineteen nineteen, when electricity was still a novelty, when most of the world didn't even have it yet. 13:08 And now in twenty twenty-five, with the entire modern grid running at full blast, renewables beat coal. And solar drove almost all of it. 13:19 In thirty-six terawatt hours of new solar generation in twenty twenty-five, the largest single year increase ever recorded from any energy source in history. 13:29 Solar alone met seventy-five percent of all new global electricity demand growth. Together, solar and wind met ninety-nine percent. Ninety-nine percent of new demand from clean sources in a single year. 13:43 And here is the part that really matters. Fossil fuel generation fell for the first time, not because of a recession or a pandemic, because of a structural shift. 13:55 Because clean power is now growing fast enough that we genuinely do not need to burn more fossil fuels to keep up with demand. That is a first. That has never happened before. China is leading. 14:09 Accounted for more than half of all global solar growth. India installed more new solar capacity than the United States for the first time ever. Battery storage costs fell forty-five percent in a single year. 14:24 The EU got forty-seven percent of its electricity from renewables. The numbers are staggering. And this is happening while the US government is doing everything it can to keep coal alive. 14:36 Which brings us to the other part of this story. Beautiful, clean coal. [laughs] So Trump has issued multiple executive orders over the past year rebranding coal as, quote, "beautiful, clean coal." 14:49 He told his staff, and this is a real quote, "Never use the word coal unless you put beautiful clean before it." He hosted a Champion of Coal event at the White House. 14:59 He directed the Pentagon to buy electricity from coal plants. He opened thirteen point one million acres of federal land for coal leasing. 15:07 He ordered the Department of Energy to distribute a hundred and seventy-five million dollars to upgrade coal plants. He is calling coal a mineral now to give it more regulatory flexibility. A mineral. 15:18 Coal, which is formed from decomposed organic matter, is now officially a mineral, so it can be treated like gold or copper under federal law because branding. And the beautiful clean part. 15:31 Let's talk about that, because there is no such thing. Burning coal will always emit the largest concentration of greenhouse gases of any fossil fuel. Full stop. 15:41 Carbon capture technology exists, but it captures zero point four percent of US emissions. Not forty percent, zero point four, and none of it is being used at coal-burning power plants anyway. 15:54 So when the White House puts out a fact sheet calling it America's beautiful clean coal power generation fleet, that is not energy policy. That is a marketing campaign for a dying industry, a rebrand. 16:06 Like if Blockbuster changed their name to Stream Max and called it the future of entertainment. And here is what makes it actually sad. 16:15 Ninety-nine percent of coal plants in the US are now more expensive to run than replacing them with renewables. Not cheaper, more expensive. The economics already lost. The market already decided. 16:31 Even the Trump administration's own data shows coal generation has been at one-third of its two thousand and seven peak. No new coal plant has come online since twenty thirteen. 16:42 The average age of the current fleet is fifty-three years old. Fifty-three years old, running on vibes and executive orders. But here is the thing. 16:51 Even with all of that, even with the US government actively fighting the transition, the global numbers show the transition is happening anyway because China and India and the EU are not waiting. 17:05 The economics are too obvious. Solar is the cheapest electricity ever produced in human history. You cannot compete with free fuel from the sun, no matter how many executive orders you sign. 17:16 Ember's analysis put it simply: This is the first time clean power kept pace with demand growth. That means from here, the math gets easier, not harder. 17:26 Every new gigawatt of solar that comes online is a gigawatt that doesn't need to come from coal or gas. The crossover point is now permanent. 17:35 For those of us who actually care about this stuff, that is enormous, because this wasn't supposed to happen this fast. The models predicted this crossover happening much later. 17:46 Solar got so cheap so fast that it basically broke the forecasts. Beautiful, clean coal can have its White House events. 17:54 It can have its executive orders, and its Champion of Coal ceremonies, and its miners in hard hats standing behind the president. The grid doesn't care about branding. 18:05 The grid cares about cost, and cost has already spoken. Renewables won. The scorecard is in. 18:13 Now we just have to make sure the policy catches up before we waste another decade burning something that the market already left behind. Okay, before we get out of here, we want to leave you with something. 18:23 We spent a lot of this episode talking about billionaires building illegal power plants, governors vetoing good bills, a government calling coal beautiful and clean with a straight face. 18:36 And it would be easy to walk away from all of that feeling like nothing is working. But then you zoom out, and renewables just beat coal for the first time in over a hundred years. 18:46 Solar grew faster than any energy source in recorded history. Communities in Memphis, and Denver, and Maine showed up and fought back. A bipartisan legislature passed a bill that said, "Slow down and do this right." 19:01 The people who benefit from the old system are loud, but they are not winning. The math is winning, the technology is winning, and the people paying attention are winning. 19:11 That is why we make this show, not to doomscroll out loud, but to actually understand what is happening, because you cannot fight what you do not understand, and you cannot build what you cannot imagine. 19:25 So thank you for being here. Thank you for giving a care. It matters more than you think. Catch us next week. More stories, more heat, more reason to believe this thing is actually moving. This is the Viro Podcast. 19:39 See you then. [upbeat music]